Russian School Teacher 'Pirate' Case Re-Opened 97
newtley writes "Russian school teacher Alexander Ponosov thought he was out from under after having been accused of 'criminally' using Microsoft product. A Russian court threw the case out, calling it 'trivial,' and Russian president Vladimir Putin said those who make "pirate" goods should be targeted, not consumers, calling the trial "utter nonsense". Now the BBCA Russian court has ordered a retrial, 'after pressure from the prosecution'. However, Ponosovhas now launched a web site. It's in Russian."
Russian website (Score:5, Funny)
Re: (Score:1, Funny)
or pointing out that in Capitalist Russia, Microsoft sues You.
So very confused...
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:1)
Windows Vista Home Basic:
# For basic home needs such as e-mail and Internet access.
# Price: $99.95
US$ 99.94 = 2,600.03904 Russian rubles
In Russia,
Bottle Vodka = 50 rubles.
60 bottles of beer = 300 rubles.
Subway ticket = 5 rubles.
3g cocaine = 3,000 rubles.
New "Russian" car = 50,000 - 75,000 rubles.
You be the judge.
Re: (Score:3, Funny)
Re: (Score:3, Interesting)
Is Windows really placing itself in the same market as illegal substances, rather than on par with the legal consumer products?
For reference, here's how your other items compare:
- Yo
Re: (Score:2)
Speaking as a non American I must insist that Budweiser is NOT beer!!!
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:1)
Eye Opener. (Score:2, Informative)
Re: (Score:2)
Not that I completely agree with that theory, but it's certainly a valid take on it.
=Smidge=
Re: (Score:2, Insightful)
Stolen Property (Score:2)
Well, buying stolen property has been illegal for many years, even though the same argument can be used to defend people prosecuted for it. How are they supposed to know, for example, that the nice car audio system they bought for $50 from a strange looking guy, was stolen?
Now, I'm not asking for a debate on whether license infringement is equivalent to stealing in all respects — just pointing out, that the argument you put forward applies (or, rather, does not apply) equally to both.
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
Well, some people also honestly don't know, that a decent car audio system can not cost $40 (and would not be sold by a homeless guy), unless stolen. In fact, I'm pretty sure, the prosecutor would have to prove, you bought it knowing, it was stolen... Without that, all they can do is return it to the rightful owner.
But if the owner finds you with it, they can claim it. To keep the analogy with software licenses, the Microsoft has the right to demand payment, and if you dont' pay, but continue using the so
Translated link (beta, of course) (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3, Interesting)
Some things are just baffling:
"It is my understanding that among readers of the magazine legally Kisbér people."
The word in the original is "shod" (as in past participle of "shoe", as in what you do to a horse), an idiom meaning "skilled/versed in". It's curious how that becom
Re: (Score:2)
No problem. I'll use it for the next round of spam e-mail I send.
Great. (Score:3, Funny)
One less pirate, one step closer to our inevitable demise due to global warming.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
Personally I just want to be allowed to graze awhile on the Giant Meatball before my turn in the Beer Volcano. I wonder if there's Parmesan?
Re: (Score:2)
One less pirate, one step closer to our inevitable demise due to global warming.
Another consequence (especially when Putin has said that this is silly): a little polonium here, a little thallium there... enjoy your sushi, Mr. Prosecutor!
Double Jeopardy (Score:1)
Either way, somehow, I have a feeling that the outcome will be totally different from what it would have been if this case did not have the publicity it is going to have...
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:1)
I wonder if double jeopardy laws would apply to such a situation in this country. I suppose it has everything to do with how the case was initially dismissed.
It wouldn't apply at all if the case was dismissed, would it? I thought you needed to be acquitted, but then IANAL.
No Microsoft prosection (Score:5, Insightful)
Microsoft has said they're not interested in prosecuting... no wonder, that would be some bad press. The guy is a school teacher, using Windows on 12 computers in the school. It's probably good news for Microsoft that he's using their software - get the kids hooked on Windows while they're young, so they'll be accustomed to using it (and possibly paying for it) later in life.
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3, Insightful)
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
I'm pretty certain they already have. "Innocently" receiving pirated software is covered under the TOS and Microsoft can, at their discretion, issue new keys.
And he's going to win at trial. He's not claiming that he has the "right" to pirate software, but that he didn't pirate it at all. He claims that he got Windows preinstalled on PCs he purchased for the c
Re: (Score:2)
What, and the prosecutor won't get his free laptop?
Obligatory (Score:5, Funny)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:1)
Just hang him now (Score:5, Funny)
Seriously, this aggression toward a relatively innocent school teacher who only wanted to give his students the best education he couldn't afford... it doesn't cause fear of piracy in the publics eye it causes ANGER.
Eventually these ridiculous lawsuits and penalties will drive the public to fix a damaged copyright system, or even drive them to embrace products that are not burdened by such copyrights. I just hope it happens soon!
Re: (Score:1)
I'm trying [slashdot.org], man. I'm trying. But it appears that people like "damaged". Too much fear of the unknown, I guess. My idea brings out the luddite* in everybody, even the moderators.
*merely meaning anti-progressive in this case
Edubuntu (Score:5, Insightful)
1. Built in Terminal Server - works well with donated (read: ancient) equipment
2. Great educational programs and games
3. It just works
4. Licensing - what licensing?
5. Maintenance and Administration - very little compared to a similar MS environment.
Perhaps more people in educational circles will see the benefit of switching from this poor teacher's incident.
Re: (Score:3, Interesting)
Re: (Score:3, Interesting)
4. Licensing - what licensing?
It has a license.. Please read it carefully. Making copies and distributing the software is permitted in the license. The license does have some restrictions including leaving out the license in your copies.
Downloads: 607
Developer: Edubuntu Team | More programs by this producer
License: GPL (GNU General Public License)
Price: FREE
Last Updated: March 23rd, 2007 18:13
Category: MAIN
http://linux.softpedi [softpedia.com]
Hmmm. (Score:1)
Re: (Score:3, Funny)
The problem with Star Trek references (Score:2)
Yeah, at the time the film came out, it was a funny joke and it's still funny, it's just not accurate. For those who don't know, the "w" sound doesn't exist in Russian at all. They would certainly say "vessels" if speaking English. "W" is most often transliterated as "v" into Russian, but they can sort of approximate the sound with something equivalent to the use of "ui" to replace "w". So I hate to burst your bubble, but this is
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
And before all the "jokes" (Score:2)
Time to Switch (Score:5, Informative)
Most distro's have a Russian language version and don't come with the litigation risk.
Re:Time to Switch (Score:4, Informative)
But there's also a vocal opposition and they do have valid arguments, and a lot of FUD along the way. For example, hired MS "experts" say that: "it's impossible to teach computer science to children without using Windows" and "Experts are united in their opinion that Linux can be used only by technically skilled people with an extensive computer knowledge" (translation is mine, original is on: http://www.permoboz.ru/txt.php?n=4971 [permoboz.ru]).
The curious thing is that Russian military already uses customized Linux (it's called MSVS
Re: (Score:2)
But seriously - that sucks - "developers" basically raped GPL - as is no source available and NO license is included with it at all. It's like 60s-70s again (when USSR stole from IBM the whole platform).
Re: (Score:2)
Hmm... That sounds like a plan:
1. Contribute code to Linux.
2. Sue Russian government for copyright infringement.
3.
3. Profit for allofmp3!
Though seriously, MSVS is just a Linux kernel with obsolete (VERY obsolete) userland and a few "nice" visual tools. It is deemed 'secure' because all of its code is thoroughly audited. And I doubt that they violate GPL too mu
Re: (Score:2)
Unfortunately the facts are starting to bust the myth. With new distro's out that are very easy to install, have working applications and much easier to keep bug free, the myth is quickly dying. I am a Linux novice. I had to crack a book to find out how to create a directory from a prompt just last week. This is inspite of having been a Ubuntu user for almost a year. From th
Re: (Score:2)
But to be fair, there ARE some usability problems with Linux. For example, how can I share _CDROM_ for the local network?
It sounds easy, but it is not (normal SMB/NFS interferes with automounting)
Re: (Score:2)
In Windows you are used to the concept of mounting a CD in the drive and sharing it via the share folder functions. You are limited by the number of CD rom drives you have.
In linux, you make an ISO of the CD and put the CD away. While your at it, make ISO's of many CD's. Mount the ISO's and share them. It's not hard.
Your choice, share a CD which anybody walking by can simply eject wit
Re:Here is a quick how-to (Score:2)
Even if another user logs in and tries to eject the CD, since they are not the owner (Didn't mount it) they do not have privilages to eject the disk. (Physical access to shutdown bypasses this.)
Here is the link;
http [idevelopment.info]
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:1)
putins right (Score:1, Interesting)
The reason there is pirated software out there is due to the pirates... This free software is an enticement and leads to people acquiring it in some way or another. If there was no enticement for free products that cost $450 then people wouldn't get them, 2 ways around this, stop piracy or lower the cost of these expensive products (windows vista, office, Maya/Softimage XSI (fo
global warming? (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
How in the world do you see this obviously 1-sided court case creating more pirates?
Russia thought it was stupid
Russia dismisses case
Outside pressure forces case to re-open without legal cause
How can this possibly end well? If he's acquitted AGAIN the outside pressures will simply increase until he's found guilty, whether he actually did it or not. Not a conducive environment to breed pirates in.
I agree with the prosecution.... (Score:5, Funny)
> out from under after having been accused of 'criminally'
> using Microsoft product"
It should be criminal to use a Microsoft product.
Re: (Score:2)
Not the whole story... (Score:5, Interesting)
During a court trial he was asked to apologize and move on but he insisted of filing an appeal to "clear his name" and play a martyr of some sort. In sum, this guy is an asshole.
If one were to put aside the bias towards Microsoft, it's clear that Panosov is being defiant, despite him being completely guilty.
I've checked his blog and he's asking his readers on how to partition the NTFS drive and install Linux alongside windows. I don't think he learned a lesson here. He's not the saintly school teacher who was unknowingly victimized by prosecutors as the media had initially reported.
Re: (Score:1)
A friend: I use OpenOffice. It's free, and I get to screw Microsoft!
Me: Yeah, but a pirated copy of Word is also free, and also screws Microsoft...
Another friend: He has a point... cheats Microsoft even more, that way.
Re: (Score:1)
So he did it to steal money? Defiance is cool. Robbery isn't.
Re: (Score:2)
Actually I think that depends. Robbing a little old lady's pension cheque is very uncool. Robbing a first world government for the amount of $3 BN is way up on the coolness list...
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:1)
toad juice sucker shares his 'thoughts' with \. (Score:4, Insightful)
Like how, he is protesting his innocence. He likes having the threat of a jail sentence hanging over his head? This is the second time a school teacher is facing jail time for using Windows. See here where a 7th grade [theregister.co.uk] teacher gets arrested when porn images pop up in the browser on a Win98 desktop. The expert prosecution witness says there is no way such images could have got on without user interaction. Something we all know is a big lie.
The teachers union on both continents should have the schools sign a do not sue waiver before touching the computer. Or maybe the EULA should be updated
'there has been talk in Russian press that he was well aware that software was illegal on dozen of the machines but still decided to cut the costs and pocket the difference'
Do you have any evidence for this wacky anecdote.
'During a court trial he was asked to apologize and move on but he insisted of filing an appeal to "clear his name" and play a martyr of some sort. In sum, this guy is an asshole'
What trial? the first case was thrown out. Also the original claim changed from piracy to illegally using the software. Even so the Judge saw fit not to proceed. Where does it say he was asked to apologize. Why would he appeal a non case. Where does it say he appealed.
'If one were to put aside the bias towards Microsoft, it's clear that Panosov is being defiant, despite him being completely guilty'
What are you smoking, toad juice? What bias? How does defending oneself in a court of law equate to being biased? I thought even in your country people are deemed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. 'Your honour the defendant is obviously guilty as he has chosen to plead innocent'
'I've checked his blog and he's asking his readers on how to partition the NTFS drive and install Linux alongside windows. I don't think he learned a lesson here. He's not the saintly school teacher who was unknowingly victimized by prosecutors as the media had initially reported'
What blog? Do you mind providing a citation to this blog where it actually says that. How in the alternate Bizarro world that you occupy does installing Linux equate to being guilty in a case of software piracy.
was Not the whole story... (Score:5, Interesting
Grammar troll strikes again! (Score:2)
What do you say, would you consider making him an acquaintance?
Re: (Score:2)
%{ #include "y.tab.h"
%}
digit [0-9]
letter [a-zA-Z]
%%
"?" { return INTERROGATIVE; }
"where" { return INTERROGATIVE; }
"what" { return INTERROGATIVE; }
"how" { return INTERROGATIVE; }
"if" { return INTERROGATIVE; }
%%
int yywrap(void){return 1;}
Re: (Score:2, Insightful)
If one were to put aside the bias towards Microsoft, it's clear that Panosov is being defiant, despite him being completely guilty.
I don't think thats clear at all. According to the Wikipedia article about this [wikipedia.org], Cnews.ru is the one reporting that he and a friend did this to embezzle money. He has denied it.
Without more evidence than journalistic hearsay, one cannot be sure.
Re: (Score:2)
How did he do this? I'm seriously asking the question because what you're implying is pretty unlikely. What HE claims is that he ordered 12 systems with 12 legal copies of Windows XP (I believe) preinstalled. He claims that the upstream vendor gave him bogus licenses. So I see 4 p
Re: (Score:1)
Russian! Pah! (Score:1)
I like the way that sounds like an accusation.
"I say, there, he's released one of those web-a-majoo-dahs I've heard so much about.
"Oh, wait, ignore that; it's in some kind of foreign language.
"*derisive laughter* Why would he bother?"
Can't believe there are no obligs on this one
Why Ninjas are Better (Score:5, Funny)
Re: (Score:2)
What about the other 0x0E kinds?
-Z
Translation. (Score:1)
Re: (Score:1)
walllll, let's see here now... (Score:3, Interesting)
but they're sparing no international pressure to destroy this educator in russia.
which lie should I believe? Bill? Monkeyboy? anybody???
I quit the MS habit cold after millenium, and my Mac does everything worth doing.
*snicker* ponos = diarrhea (Score:2)
I can't help it, it's funny (Score:1)
hehehehehe
In Soviet Russia... (Score:1)
Work on Translation - (Score:1)
Is the reader of the book are criminal? (Score:1)