Proposed Legislation Is Mooninite Fallout 280
theantipop writes "Ars Technica has a story about the Terrorist Hoax Improvements Act, a bill introduced recently by the Senate. The bill aims to 'amend the federal criminal code to include a number of new clauses meant to up the ante on wasting government resources. The amendments include extensions to the prohibitions on the spread of false information and mailing threats, increases to maximum prison terms, and allowances for civil suits so that local and federal governments can attempt to recoup expenses related to an incident.' This is undoubtedly a reaction to the Great Mooninite Scare of 2007."
Eh? (Score:5, Interesting)
Wait a minute here. How the hell can the government enter into civil suits?
These are suits which are outside of the usual prosecutorial parts of the justice system -- ie civilian.
They can pass a law to make it a crime, but I can't imagine the badness of the precedent of governments being able to take civil action. Take criminal action, or bugger off. You can't really ask to do both.
Does this even have a valid basis in law?
Cheers
won't happen (Score:3, Interesting)
Spread of false information? (Score:3, Interesting)
did not RTFA, but the government is the single largest distributor of false information around...
everything from telling us that reducing your cholesterol intake will lower your risk of heart disease (false) to telling us there were WMDs in Iraq.
seems like they're going to need a "no tag backs" clause in this one.
Report everything! (Score:3, Interesting)
Something along the lines of: "You wanted to be notified of any suspicious devices or activities? Well theres a paper bag lying on the ground here at (insert location) and noone seems to know anything about it. Its big enough to hold a few sticks of dynamite or something. Just being a good citizen, sir!".
If the 'authorities' want to take *obvious* stuff like the mooninites publicity stunt *that* seriously then let them try to apply the same level of serious for any notification of 'suspect objects'.
The problem of stupid overreaction on the part of the 'authorities' will go away very very quickly.
Boston (Score:2, Interesting)
Um, wasnt the boston government the ones "spreading false information" and making bomb threats?
Re:Watch out for DHMO (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:Thus, ever higher (Score:5, Interesting)
Increasingly draconian sententencing is rather counter-productive in the sense that it may help increase the severity of crimes performed, or the desperation of those close to being nabbed.
Re:Two sides to every story (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Spread of false information? (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Thus, ever higher (Score:5, Interesting)
We had to break the law to get our paintballs, and we had to chose the option that was not only illegal, but highly immoral. It's certainly sophomoric logic, but I'm pretty sure it's the type of logic that would prevail in an over-lawed state.
Re:A story from the military (Score:5, Interesting)
He was hardly an isolated incident unfortunately. The list of horrendous acts drunken members of the military have done in Okinawa is rather staggering. It was with good reason that the protesters were at our gates.
-Rick
Re:A story from the military (Score:2, Interesting)
On the one hand, it's always good news that that wasn't a bomb on your doorstep. On the other hand, aside from the time and money wasted, that particular General probably got a few new fun nicknames.
Nation of Cowards (Score:3, Interesting)
So, let me get this straight, betwetters. Every time I experience an object, sound, or symbol I don't recognize, or one which reminds me of something that could be used to inflict harm, somebody should go to jail?
If you want your safety guaranteed to an arbitrary degree, well, I guess we'll have the brain in a vat plan available fairly soon. And before that, you're welcome to check yourself into total a surveillance camp. For the rest of us, a little common sense and a modicum of dignity will just have to get us by.
Seriously, the best way, long term, to get people to make rational decisions throughout the day would be early exposure, in school, to elementary logic, statistics, and game theory. As important as pure math is, I think that this should be a separate set of classes, because... well, it'll be easier to market it if you tie it to real life. Here are a couple books I think should be required reading in high school:
Innumeracy [amazon.com]
Prisoner's Dilemma [amazon.com]
Re:Great Advertising (Score:3, Interesting)
Box office details. [boxofficemojo.com]