New Plan In UK For "Big Brother" Database 178
POPE Mad Mitch writes "The BBC is reporting that Tony Blair is going to unveil plans on Monday to build a single database to pull together and share every piece of personal data from all government departments. The claimed justification is to improve public services. The opposition party and the Information Commission have both condemned the plan as another step towards a 'Big Brother' society. Sharing information in this way is currently prohibited by the 'over-zealous' data protection legislation. An attempt to build a similar database was a key part of the, now severely delayed, ID card scheme."
Re:Good luck... (Score:5, Interesting)
Does this ring a bell? (Score:2, Interesting)
Scale & Risk (Score:5, Interesting)
It seems perverse that anyone would consider this a remotely reasonable plan.
The article doesn't look at the technical side of doing this at all, but its pretty obvious that todo what they are talking about doing here, it means restructuring the data for hundreds if not thousands of applications that are in use now.
Why is the UK government so gung-ho on these 'MegaIT Projects'?
Lets hope this dosen't get traction, but as with most things 'New Labour', I can only imagine this is signed and sealed now that the public are being made aware
25 years early: Britrockers Judas Priest (Score:5, Interesting)
My lasers trace, everything you do,
You think you've private lives, think nothing of the kind
There is no true escape, I'm watching all the time!
CHORUS:
I'm made of metal, my circuits gleam
I am perpetual, I keep the country clean.
I'm elected, electric spy,
I'm protected, electric eye.
Always in focus, you can't feel my stare,
I zoom into you, you dont know I'm there.
I take a pride in probing, all your secret moves,
My tearless retina takes, pictures that can prove.
Electric eye (in the sky)
Feel my stare (always there)
There's nothing you can do about it, develop and expose,
I feed upon your every thought, and so my power grows!
I'm made of metal, my circuits gleam
I am perpetual, I keep the country clean.
I'm elected, electric spy,
I'm protected, electric eye.
I'm Elected - Protected - Detective - Electric - Eye.
- Judas Priest, Electric Eye, 1982.
25 years ago, this was cheesy hair-metal dystopic science fiction.
Sucks to be us.
Mega IT projects suck (Score:4, Interesting)
In any event, I agree with the other commentators that this is a pork project more than anything.
Re:European Digital Privacy Directive? (Score:4, Interesting)
Cost of Information (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:UK, US, doesn't matter really (Score:1, Interesting)
Re:Scale & Risk (Score:5, Interesting)
What they do is propose something outrageously distateful, which gets parliament in uproar - while all the time they only planned something merely somewhat distateful. Parliament gets uppity, votes on it, and gets the legislation watered down to the 'somewhat distasteful' level, thinking they've won a victory. Basically, the government proposes the most draconian legislation possible and lets parliament scale it back to something they will accept, which is probably much more draconian than if they had just tried to pass what they wanted to pass in the first place.
Re:Scale & Risk (Score:3, Interesting)
Yes, they've done this repeatedly, most obviously with things like detention without trial, where the 90 days originally requested were scaled back to "only" several times the historical limit and the limit used in pretty much every other first world nation.
It's really odd how this works. It's as if everyone is so used to the government (with its unjustified absolute majority in Parliament) forcing through any legislation they want, no matter how unpopular, that the people making the decisions now consider the default to be the bad alternative proposed by the government and not status quo, and judge any revised proposals in that light. I'm not sure whether this is a more damning indictment of the calibre of people who make decisions in our country, or of the electoral system that gives an absolute majority to a group that gained the support of only just over 1/5 of the electorate.